
Who Answers Supplier Questionnaires? In Most Small Businesses, Nobody Was Given The Job
Blake Manchester4 min read
Usually the owner, on a Sunday. Who answers supplier questionnaires is a question almost no Australian business has decided, because the work turned up without a job title attached. Your largest customers now carry climate reporting obligations. You do not. They can ask you anyway, and the Productivity Commission put that in writing yesterday.
Outstaffer sells employment and the compliance work that comes with it, so take what follows as an interested argument.
What the Productivity Commission said about supplier questionnaires
The interim report of its inquiry into business reporting requirements landed on 19 November. Interim finding 3.1 is the line to read twice. Scope 3 emissions reporting, it says, can impose costs on businesses “that are not themselves subject to mandatory sustainability reporting”.
Scope 3 means the emissions in a company’s value chain rather than its own operations. The reporting entity discloses them. You, its supplier, report nothing. You just get asked.
The Council of Small Business Organisations Australia put it to the inquiry more bluntly. “The small supplier has no reporting obligation of its own, but must answer to win or keep the work.”
Who is doing the asking?
On the Commission’s estimate 2,124 entities sit inside the regime once it is fully phased in, 729 of them in Group 1. Every one has a supply chain, and most of that chain is businesses your size.
The asking costs them almost nothing, which is the problem
Treasury estimated a Group 1 entity would pay around $50,000 for assurance in its first year of reporting. The Purpose Bureau and Monash Business School examined more than 290 early Group 1 reports and found a median assurance fee of about $89,000 among the 16 per cent that disclosed one. Nexia told the inquiry the original estimate understated average assurance costs by a factor of 2.25.
So your customer is carrying an assurance bill close to twice what it budgeted, with an auditor asking for evidence. Emailing you a spreadsheet costs it nothing and lowers its own risk. COSBOA named the mechanism: “a bounded obligation on the reporting entity can generate a much broader appetite to ask.”
Your side of that trade has no number against it. The report prices the reporting entities in a table, to two decimal places. For what a supplier spends answering, it carries submissions and no figure. We have priced an hour of back office admin at $48 from Australian Bureau of Statistics earnings data, and counted the admin hours an allied health practice absorbs.
This task is the one cost in the regime with nothing beside it.
What a supplier questionnaire can be answered with
AASB S2 does not require primary data from suppliers. Scope 3 emissions may be estimated using secondary data or industry averages, and a reporting entity need only use information available without undue cost or effort. The Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry has told producers in as many words that farm-level data is not mandatory and that they can ask whether industry averages were considered first.
So should you refuse?
No, and the counter-argument deserves a fair hearing. Its obligation is real, its assurance costs came in at nearly double the estimate, and primary data from you is the cheapest way to satisfy an auditor. From that chair it is a reasonable email to send.
What makes it costly is that it can arrive in different formats from different customers, each wanting it their own way. The Commission’s own reform direction is that suppliers should be able to calculate the information once and reuse it across customers. That concedes the current state of play.
Related reading
Give the questionnaire an owner before Christmas
Submissions close on 18 December and the final report goes to government in February, so the asking is not stopping this summer.
Decide now who answers supplier questionnaires, write the standard answer once, and keep it where the next person can find it. It is small, repeatable and documented, which is exactly the kind of work that does not need to sit on a founder. Sign up and run one role through it if you would rather it sat elsewhere. Reporting obligations may apply differently to your business, so get advice on your own circumstances.
So who read the last one, and what did they send back?
Posted in Global Hiring category




